The Chosen Two Archive
A Buffy/Faith Fanfiction Community

The Chosen Two Archives

BROWSE BY:

Relationship [278]
Season [231]
Character
Genre

Archive Links:

Twitter
Awards
Tumblr
Links

Site Info

Members: 1536
Series: 20
Stories: 289
Chapters: 1550
Word count: 7908585
Authors: 58
Reviews: 2554
Reviewers: 156
Newest Member: elamanuela
 

Search





Reviews For Guilty Secret

Name: Deadpool (Signed) · Date: 09/04/2014 04:36 AM · For: Chapter 25

I absolutely loved this. Thank you.



Author's Response: Glad you enjoyed it. Thanks for the feedback.


Name: Wixy (Signed) · Date: 09/19/2013 01:30 PM · For: Chapter 12

Well it seems the path is sorta clear now... I'm glad jack came to his senses,,, it's not fun being in a one sided relationship, in fact it sucks! So jack was right to let Buffy go! He was being a bit of a dick but I guess when u r that desperately in love you do and say stupid things to keep a hold of something.. Even if it equates to nothing :(

Buffy will do well not to jump into anything with faith; faith has a lot to prove to Buffy so that when the time is right they can be together.. How god intended it! Hehe! Looking forward to the next chapter(s)! :)))))))



Author's Response:

Thanks for the feedback.

Is the path ever smooth for these two? Not when I'm writing the story it seems!



Name: Wixy (Signed) · Date: 09/11/2013 10:34 AM · For: Chapter 10

What a treat - two chapters!

The slayer dream was just lovely to read.

I see a pattern emerging: when buffy and faith do the dirty, instead of basking they end up arguing! 

So the 'easy' way out is for Buffy to let Jack keep walking... in a way it would probably be best for all...

I hope Faith does come out of her coma... and that its soon... very soon!

Til the next time :) 

 



Author's Response:

Read this review, told myself not to forget to respond, then completely forgot! So, a little later than I intended.... Thanks for the feedback, glad you're enjoying it.



Name: Wixy (Signed) · Date: 09/10/2013 10:21 AM · For: Chapter 8

I wonder if Faith had said anything to Buffy on her WEDDING DAY (!) about her feelings of love how much of a difference that would make... I'm trying to put myself in Buffy's shoes and if someone I once loved told me they wanted to be with me on my wedding day i would have just told them its too late... Luckily no such thing did happen!

 

Anyway I digress (again!) I'm still with you on this fic and I'm intrigued to know what has happened to Faith and really wonder when Jack is gonna wake up and smell the coffee... he's so badly in denial it's uncomfortable! 

 

Buffy being pregnant is adding so much more complexity to this saga and i'm looking forward to see how you take this story forward.



Author's Response:

Thanks for the feedback, much appreciated.

Ahh, the what ifs of life, they plague us all.



Name: Wixy (Signed) · Date: 08/30/2013 05:42 AM · For: Chapter 5

hmmmmm... I'm not too happy with Buffy now! She's a bit of a bitch! Never thought I'd say that about her but this chapter has shone a lot of light onto Jack's character and he hasnt been anything short of amazing to Buffy.

I feel sorry for the guy, I do, but at the same time he did go into this saga with his eyes wide open... Buffy couldn't stop banging on about Faith from the moment they met, to their first date and now whilst they're married! RED FLAGS all over the place Jack!!! 

But i guess it all falls back onto the notion that we cant help who we fall in love with...



Author's Response:

Thanks for the feedback, glad you're enjoying it. Don't feel too sorry for Jack! Like you said, he knew what he was getting into. And if only Buffy and Faith weren't so stubborn and difficult they wouldn't be in this situation.



Name: Wixy (Signed) · Date: 08/27/2013 10:57 AM · For: Chapter 4

Uh oh! I had a feeling that stupid history was gonna go and stupidly repeat it's stupid's self! Huff!!!

At first I was pretty miffed with Buffy but I'm totally on her side now. Faith is being a spoilt brat IMO!! She just keeps running away and and expecting Buffy to be there to scratch that itch... cos that's all it is...!

Faith's reaction in the flashback and then the present day is totally out of order... 

BUT... there's always a stupid BUT! You can't help who you love and although I'm screaming at Buffy that Faith is an idiot, I kinda, to a very small degree, but a degree none-the-less, get where she's coming from. *sigh*

Love is bitch... sometimes!

I feel sorry Jack, but if it turns out he's also screwing around (bowling? a likely story!) then I don't!

Oh god! I feel down in the dumps now! Gonna cry in my pillow!!

Looking forward to your next update :)

 

 



Author's Response:

Thanks for the feedback, glad you're enjoying it.



Name: Wixy (Signed) · Date: 08/27/2013 04:17 AM · For: Chapter 3

Aaaarrgghhh!!! its just so goddam frustrating knowing they could have avoided having this affair... i really want to know what the hell happened to get them in this situation...

so it would seem from the flashback that Faith was willing to give the relationship a go... so what did she do in order to drive buffy into the arms of another person and to end up marrying that person? grrr.. i guess I'll inch closer to that question as i read more!

I loved the conversation between willow and buffy - it struck a chord with me...

And cant deny that the opening of this chapter was great! Its how every chapter of every fuffy fic should commence!!! 

still lovin this one!



Name: Wixy (Signed) · Date: 08/22/2013 11:17 AM · For: Chapter 2

My instincts were right! I like this story A LOT! 

I like how the story isnt told chronologically - you write it really well.

I'm trying to write something with a similar narrative - in some parts it's quite similar to what I'm writing, which is a lil spooky! But at the same time what I'm writing is quite different... so fear not! Also it is an AU fic. 

Anyway going off on a tangent there, I'm really eager to find out how Buffy and Faith got to the point where they are having an affair, when they could have been together from the outset... makes me wonder about the integrity of their 'relationship'... Are they having the affair cos its exciting and non commitment-y? Well actually I guess integrity goes outta the window when you cheat on your husband/wife! Ah going off on another tangent! 

So back to you... I'll read the next chapter soon and will leave a comment and try not to go off on any tangents!

Til then...



Author's Response:

Thanks for the feedback, glad you're enjoying it.

Good luck with your story. Keeping track of everything that was going on in their separate lives just about drive me mad when I was writing this!



Name: Wixy (Signed) · Date: 08/16/2013 05:55 AM · For: Chapter 1

Oooo I really like this fic so far... 

I'm a bit confused on how the chapter has ended though.. After the TBC there is a random conversation (seems to be a flashback) but it seems a little out of context?? Or maybe I'm reading it wrong..

That aside... I enjoyed reading this and get the feeling it'll be up there amongst the handful of favourite fuffy fics I have read in recent times.

Thanks for sharing and I look forward to updates. 



Author's Response:

Thanks for pointing that out, it was an error of some sort. That was part of the conversation between Buffy and Faith just before they went for breakfast. Put it back in the right spot now.



You must login (register) to review.